G. Fwonyon, the deputy director of Public Prosecution in Plateau State, had told the court that John, in company of an accomplice also named John (now at large), robbed the woman on November 18, 2005 in her shop at Gada Biu, Jos at gunpoint.
Counsel to John, Tobechukwu Kekemeke, rejected the prosecutor’s claim and accused the police of “not telling the truth about the gun” said to have been used by John.
Kekemeke pointed out that the police presented three statements, with only the last indicating a confession by the accused that he used a gun against the victim. The defence counsel further argued that the prosecution had failed to prove to the court that the accused actually used a gun to commit the act.
He asked the court to throw out the case for lack of diligent prosecution, arguing that “the circumstances of the third statement, in which John was said to have admitted ownership of the gun, is suspect.”
In a 60-page judgement, Justice Yargata Nimpa said the evidence before the court had shown that the accused committed the offence. He therefore sentenced John to death by hanging.
“The accused is hereby sentenced to death by hanging, but the judgement is liable to an appeal,” Nimpa declared.
Kekemeke noted that he will appeal against the judgement.
“The convict has the right to appeal against the judgement. It is not a judgement that we are satisfied with, so we are definitely going to appeal at the Court of Appeal,” he vowed.